Renault Captur Forums banner
1 - 1 of 1 Posts

Premium Member
255 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
The Renault Captur could have been safer for rear passengers, a Renault executive has admitted, had curtain airbags been fitted to the car.

The controversial decision to make full-length curtain airbags unavailable in the Renault Captur follows the decision first made with the Clio hatchback range last year, when Renault argued that the rate of rear passenger occupancy was low in light hatchbacks. But it has now mimicked that decision with its Captur sub-compact SUV ""“ a car directly targeted at families.

Renault claims that the introduction of stability control, in concert with the low rate of rear passenger occupancy, means the chance of a fatal side collision is low. It also argues that both the Clio and Captur are good enough to achieve a five-star Euro NCAP safety rating, and that their seat-mounted front-side airbags do a better job of protecting front passengers than traditional roof-mounted curtains.

On the Euro NCAP website, however, it references as part of the reason for its side impact test (below), which thwarts the side of the car into a pole at 29km/h, that in an ""impact without the head protecting airbag, a driver's head could hit the pole with sufficient force to cause a fatal head injury.""�

In that test, the pole collides with the exact point of the driver's hip, further away from rear passengers. Euro NCAP does not test side impacts directly into the rear doors and rear passenger hip point, yet in a real-world crash it is entirely possible that a pole, tree or car could hit directly into the rear door.

Euro NCAP goes on to say that ""a side impact airbag with head protection makes this kind of crash [pole impact] survivable despite the severity.""�

Renault deputy program director Christophe Pejout claims that with the Clio and Captur's full length vertical front-side airbag, mounted in the front seats, ""the driver and front passenger are better protected""� when compared with traditional curtain airbags. This is likely the reason why the Clio and Captur score highly in that very specific driver-focused Euro NCAP test.

Asked directly whether rear passengers of a Clio or Captur would be safer with airbag protection, Pejout admitted that ""probably yes, all other things equal""¦""�

Pejout believes that ""ESC remains an answer to some of the accidents""� but concedes that ESC cannot prevent another car from hitting a Clio or Captur when emerging from an intesection, for example.

""Crash cases for rear passengers are very few ""¦ because occupation for rear passengers is very low,""� continues Pejout.

Asked why this is the case when the Captur is targeted at young families, the deputy project manager clarified: ""a young family ""¦ but with children [booster] rear seats.""�

He said that Renault must prioritise certain safety development in the case of specific cars and cited that right now ""pedestrian safety is important also""�.

""In growing markets like China, India, the majority of dead people are pedestrians,""� he added.

He believes the Euro NCAP is the standard by which buyers rate the safety of their new car, and that safety developments within Renault are ""a constant evolution [with] Euro NCAP protocol.

""In two or three years, the protocol may be different again.""�

But the Euro NCAP protocol currently does not have a test that specifically covers side impacts targeted on the rear doors""¦
1 - 1 of 1 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.